Grace Ellis Reviews “Mystery at Chilmark” by Dianne Hunt Smith

“Mystery at Chilmark” follows Kat as she explores her family history and finds a spiritual connection with an ancestor. Dianne Hunt Smith’s descriptions thoroughly flesh-out Kat’s hometown with charming imagery while simultaneously explaining the history of Kat’s ancestors. The book ultimately centers around Chilmark, and allows Kat to engage with her childhood surroundings while also uncovering several mysteries. The story keeps a good pace, allowing Kat to find just enough clues to keep the readers in anticipation.

The story has a personal feel to it. It confines the overall plot to just a few characters and settings, making it feel focused and intimate. The contrast of natural and supernatural also feels new and refreshing, especially since Kat (after her initial surprise) takes each event in stride. The plot comes together full-circle by the end, concluding satisfactorily while also hinting at just enough to make readers want more. I’ll be looking forward to more mysteries from the Eye in the Sky series!